Elliott Bignell
2 min readJul 6, 2023

Yes, there is a difference between the nationalism of those who already have a nation-state, and seek to assert its inherent superiority over others, and the nationalism of those who seek a nation-state of their own. I am often confronted with this over the nationalism of the Celtic "fringes", especially Scotland, with which the left tends to sympathise, vis a vis English supremacist nationalism, which the left tends to abhor. My answer is that it is a fallacy of equivocation to compare the two: The nationalism of Brexit and the nationalism of independence movements are two only distantly related sympathies which unfortunately share a name. There is an obvious contrast between the nationalism of an oppressed people and the nationalism of their oppressor; between a nation seeking freedom and a nation denying freedom.

My personal view of the nation-state is that it was an inherently liberal idea: That all white males would live together under a system of common laws and governance in which all shared certain common rights as citizens. It was a notion that set Enlightenment societies apart from feudalism, and as such always sat uncomfortably in the same boat as a monarchy. The left has tended to reject the notion that this system enfolds only white males, whereas the right are today seeking a regression to precisely that restriction.

But more than anything, the cynic in me thinks that liberals have tended to shy away from nationalism since it proved such a murderous influence in the 19th and 20th Centuries; the right has tended ever more to embrace the nation as a right-wing property for precisely the same reason. The Enlightenment provided liberal ideas which seemed good at the time; conservatives start to claim they were their ideas all along once they've been proven not to work.

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

Elliott Bignell
Elliott Bignell

Written by Elliott Bignell

Software engineer, photographer, cook, bedroom guitarist and karateka

No responses yet

Write a response